Page 1 of 3

Building a bentside spinet

Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 8:07 pm
by Charlie Schultz
This will be based on the Keene & Brackley 1715 spinet, described in John Barnes' book "Making a Spinet".

First up, the form for making the bentside. The bentside 750 mm long, 176 mm wide and 9 mm thick (tapers to 7.1 mm at the towards the sharpest part of the bend). Barnes makes the case that the wood was typically just soaked in (cold) water and bent on the form. This is my interpretation of the bending form (minus the hold down clamps).
Capture.PNG
The walls are a couple layers of 15 mm BB plywood, with 1.25" dowels for the spacers (using 12" bolts through the dowels to old it all together).

My plan is to soak and use a hot air gun.

Questions
1. Should the outside walls of the form be beyond the edges of the side? Or should the edges of the side ride on the outside walls.
2. Do you think SuperSoft would help?

Re: Building a bentside spinet

Posted: Sat Sep 17, 2016 8:26 pm
by Barry Daniels
Supersoft should work. Are you using veneer?

Re: Building a bentside spinet

Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2016 12:30 pm
by Charlie Schultz
Plan 'A' is full thickness. I plan to use cherry for the case and lid, poplar for the baseboard and spruce for the soundboard.

Re: Building a bentside spinet

Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2016 1:09 pm
by Barry Daniels
Supersoft works well on guitar side thickness (0.080") but much thicker than that will be less effective due to the lack of penetration. I recommend resawing the wood into thin layers and doing a bent lamination. The other option would be making a steam box.

Re: Building a bentside spinet

Posted: Wed Sep 21, 2016 11:19 am
by Charlie Schultz
I misinterpreted John's bending form, I think this is more like it:
Capture.PNG
The board to be bent rides on top of the cross pieces.

Re: Building a bentside spinet

Posted: Wed Sep 21, 2016 4:37 pm
by Barry Daniels
Either form should work but you would actually get more support on the first one due to the form's edges also contacting the wood during bending. This is just the way that a Fox Bender form works.

Re: Building a bentside spinet

Posted: Tue Sep 27, 2016 6:43 am
by Charlie Schultz
If I was going to do laminations, the first one would be the way to go. But I wanted to try bending full thickness.

Here's my form (wood to be bent is leaning up against the back):
IMG_20160926_190006413.png
And the bend:
IMG_20160926_201208661.png
I don't think my heat gun was quite up to the task (it could not keep a big area hot) so I wound up pouring boiling water on it for a while (and bending slowly). Per the plan, this form should overbend the side to account for springback. I will leave it in the form while I work on the baseboard (case bottom).

Re: Building a bentside spinet

Posted: Mon Oct 03, 2016 7:02 am
by Charlie Schultz
Here is the baseboard. It is poplar, about 0.5" (12.5mm) thick. The bentside (on the right) still needs to be trimmed. Barnes recommends waiting until the case is ready to be assembled before trimming it (the baseboard) to match the actual bent side. The long edge (back) is about 1.7m or 68" long. The long rectangle in the front is where the keys will be.
IMG_20161002_132025720.png

Re: Building a bentside spinet

Posted: Tue Oct 04, 2016 6:25 am
by Charlie Schultz
Here is the wrestplank or pin block (what holds the tuning pins). I've used maple, 3.4 cm (1.3") thick. It will sit just in back and above the keyboard- you can see the left edge follows the baseboard outline. It will sit about 3" above the baseboard, allowing the keyboard levers to go underneath.
IMG_20161003_185839015.png
The jack guides are next and they are a bit involved (and there are about 30 of them) so it may be a week or two before the next update.

Re: Building a bentside spinet

Posted: Tue Oct 11, 2016 8:07 am
by Charlie Schultz
I'm working on the jack guides and doing it a little different than the book. The jack guides are built up from a pattern of notches in the wood, then the wood is cut into the individual blocks (we need 29 of them). In the book, the notch borders are cut with a handsaw and then they are chiseled out to make the grooves. I'm going to use a tablesaw instead.

So here is a photo of the notches cut in some cherry that has been planed to a thickness of 12.3 mm. If I had a wider piece of cherry, I could have repeated the pattern horizontally. After the notches are all cut, the length is cut into 29 mm long blocks.
IMG_20161006_200849865.jpg
Next, a little jig is made to hold the blocks (now standing on edge). You can see that the notches on the back side line up with the notches on the top to create the jack guide. The angle (nominally 26.5 degrees) will vary slightly depending on the actual thickness of the cut. We need the octave span to be about 165 mm.
IMG_20161008_192114053.jpg
Here's a group glued up. I glued up 7 - 9 pieces at a time, then glued them all together. Next I need to cut off the top and bottom so we have a flat surface to glue to the wrestplank.
IMG_20161010_190229742.jpg

Re: Building a bentside spinet

Posted: Mon Oct 17, 2016 7:53 am
by Charlie Schultz
Jack guide with edges trimmed off, just about ready to be mounted to the wrestplank
IMG_20161015_191447820.jpg
And glued to the wrest plank. The bass & treble ends have been squared off and a slight (2 degree) bevel was added to allow the jacks to move easily in the guides. The top surface of the guide is planed smooth with the top of the wrestplank.
IMG_20161016_130224248.jpg

Re: Building a bentside spinet

Posted: Mon Oct 17, 2016 10:03 pm
by Eric Knapp
I'm really fascinated by this. I'm really looking forward to seeing it develop.

-Eric

Re: Building a bentside spinet

Posted: Thu Oct 20, 2016 7:00 am
by Charlie Schultz
I added the soundboard liners around the jack guide/wrestplank assembly- this is where the soundboard will attach to the jack guides. Sort of like kerfing on a guitar except it's not kerfed and it is a bit lower than the guides (so that the top of the soundboard will be flush with the guides and wrestplank). Per the drawing, the soundboard is 1.55 to 1.75 mm thick along this edge.
IMG_20161019_144048473.jpg
Next I cut the baseboard liners and put them in position (but not glued down yet).
IMG_20161019_144127967.jpg
Then here are a couple photos of the wrestplank assembly sitting in its place. I still have to add a couple spacer strips between the wrestplank and baseboard.
IMG_20161019_144107272.jpg
IMG_20161019_144038289.jpg
I need to read a little further ahead before I glue things down here- there are still some things shown on the drawing that I don't get yet.

Re: Building a bentside spinet

Posted: Tue Oct 25, 2016 8:08 am
by Charlie Schultz
Some questions for anyone that might know...

There are a couple of "sloping" shelves shown on the drawing, but I cannot find any reference to them in the booklet. I'm not sure what their purpose is. The first is shown in the following drawing- the sloped wedge on the right baseboard liner, presumably right in front of the wrestplank assembly.
Perspective
Perspective
From the plan
From the plan
The second "sloping" shelf looks to be the horizontal baseboard liner shown in the drawing below. Now, it does slope left to right, but the booklet clearly says this liner is glued down but the plan notes that it is just nailed. So perhaps just the top is sloped? Or I'm just misinterpreting?
Top view
Top view
IMG_20161024_192825736.jpg

Re: Building a bentside spinet

Posted: Fri Oct 28, 2016 12:11 pm
by Charlie Schultz
One of the folks over on the hpschd-l mailer clued me in. There is another thin board that slopes upward from the baseboard liner to the back of the wrestplank assembly and it basically encloses the keyboard area. He also pointed out that you can see a small portion of it (now that I know what to look for) in one of the photos on John Barnes' web site.

Re: Building a bentside spinet

Posted: Fri Dec 30, 2016 5:35 pm
by Bob Francis
This is fascinating.

Re: Building a bentside spinet

Posted: Thu Jan 12, 2017 10:31 am
by Charlie Schultz
Sorry for the lapse, it's been busy.

I got the case pieces all planed to thickness and at least rough cut. Here's about how they go:
IMG_20170108_110000078.jpg
Per the book, I'm starting to fit them from the front, winding up with the long back piece being the last to install. Here is the detail on one of the sides that goes next to the keyboard:
IMG_20170108_111835792_HDR.jpg
You can see a rabbet along the bottom edge- there is a long, thin piece of spruce that goes from the front to the back of the keywell for reinforcement. I think the historically correct way was to not rabbet the piece, but instead add a veneer (pecan) the same thickness as the spruce strip.

So I got the left side cut to proper lengths and mitered and I started on the right side- got the first two pieces done ok but now it was time to add the curved piece (which has been sitting in the bending jig all this time). Unfortunately, the bend did not come out well enough. 90% of it fit well, but the last 10% (the end nearest the keyboard) was significantly under bent. Not sure yet what I did wrong, but I steamed it last night and put it back in the jig- we'll see tonight if it's any better.

Re: Building a bentside spinet

Posted: Thu Jan 12, 2017 4:22 pm
by Bob Francis
This is totally fascinating and WAY out of my league.
Thank you

Re: Building a bentside spinet

Posted: Sat Jan 14, 2017 12:15 am
by Randy Roberts
I'm with Bob and Eric in being really interested in this project you're tackling.

If your bent piece ends up not working out, I definitely would vote for doing it as a lamination next try. It would be a lot more structurally stable I think.

Where did you source your spruce for dimensions large enough for the soundboard?

Have you found a forum of similar builders you can draw on? If not, you ought to add a new category here for keyboard instruments.

Re: Building a bentside spinet

Posted: Sat Jan 14, 2017 2:48 pm
by Beate Ritzert
Where is the applause button? I am really fascinated.